News | Law and Order
16 Feb 2025 5:52
NZCity News
NZCity CalculatorReturn to NZCity

  • Start Page
  • Personalise
  • Sport
  • Weather
  • Finance
  • Shopping
  • Jobs
  • Horoscopes
  • Lotto Results
  • Photo Gallery
  • Site Gallery
  • TVNow
  • Dating
  • SearchNZ
  • NZSearch
  • Crime.co.nz
  • RugbyLeague
  • Make Home
  • About NZCity
  • Contact NZCity
  • Your Privacy
  • Advertising
  • Login
  • Join for Free

  •   Home > News > Law and Order

    Inside the Qatari royal family's legal battle over The Idol's Eye diamond, worth more than $27 million

    The pale blue stone has passed through the hands of royals, art collectors, sultans and aristocracy – but who does it belong to now?


    The Idol's Eye is a 70.21-carat diamond reportedly valued at more than $27 million, thought to be the world's largest cut blue diamond.

    It is just 2.6cm long and 2.45cm wide.

    This week, however, the tiny, pale blue stone made headlines around the world as the subject of a bitter court battle between two branches of Qatar's royal family.

    For a diamond found in 1600 and passed through the hands of royals, art collectors, sultans and aristocracy, there was a single question that needed to be answered.

    Was The Idol's Eye for sale?

    The 'limpid' diamond discovered in an Indian mine

    When it comes to diamonds, there are few more prized than those hacked from mines near the Golconda fort in India.

    The Hope Diamond, the Regent Diamond, the Kohinoor — and, yes, The Idol's Eye — were excavated from the area's mine.

    According to Christie's auction house, the ruined city near Hyderabad was once the "bustling centre" of the world's diamond industry.

    [youtube]

    "'Golconda' is a name used within the jewellery world to denote the world's finest diamonds," it wrote.

    "[These are] gems that possess superb luminousness, transparency and an innate purity."

    Golconda diamonds, according to Christie's, have a higher degree of transparency — the light "appears to pass through the stone as if it were totally unimpeded".

    By the 17th century, the diamond industry was booming.

    And it was at this point, with tens of thousands of workers on the hunt for the precious stones, that The Idol's Eye was first discovered.

    Though there is little evidence to back it up, the diamond is surrounded by stories of idol worship, theft, kidnapping and debt collection, according to the Antique Jewelry University.

    The Idol's Eye was said to have been owned by a Persian prince before being seized as payment for debts. Following this unsubstantiated story, it reportedly disappeared for almost 300 years.

    Its first authenticated appearance was in a Christie's London saleroom in 1865.

    From there, it went to the 34th Ottoman Sultan, Abd al-Hamid II, until he was overthrown, according to Christie's.

    "In an attempt to dispatch his jewels to safety, The Idol's Eye was stolen by the servant entrusted with it," the auction house said.

    The diamond went on to auction in Paris, then to a Spanish nobleman, then to the "King of Diamonds" Harry Winston in 1946.

    Set in the middle of 152 diamonds on a necklace and passing through several more hands over the following decades, it was acquired by Sheikh Saud bin Mohammed Ali Al-Thani sometime after 2001.

    And that is where our legal battle starts to unfold.

    The son, the daughter and the Swiss lawyer

    Shiekh Saud — Qatari prince, minister of culture, arts and heritage, and avid art collector — loaned the diamond to his second cousin once removed in early 2014.

    The cousin, Sheikh Hamad bin Abdullah Al Thani, is the chief executive of private investment company Qipco Holdings.

    Elanus Holdings, a company linked to Shiekh Saud, loaned Qipco the diamond for 20 years.

    If Elanus wanted to sell, Qipco had the right to buy The Idol's Eye for either $US10 million ($15.81 million), or the average estimated value given by two major auction houses.

    At the end of 2014, Shiekh Saud died.

    His family went back and forth over potentially selling the stone to settle debts but, according to documents from London's High Court, the discussion "fizzled out".

    His son, Sheikh Hamad bin Saud Al-Thani, again returned to potentially selling the diamond in early 2020.

    "[I] thought that if I found something that might excite me and my family, they might be persuaded to consider a sale of The Idol's Eye to fund the purchase of new assets," he told the court.

    Dieter Neupert, a Swiss-based lawyer, was asked to provide a contract for the sale.

    Dr Neupert notified Qipco the family wished to sell The Idol's Eye in February 2020, court documents said.

    Sheikh Saud's daughter, Sheikha Sara bint Saoud Al-Thani, said the first time she heard of the proposed sale was in March.

    "She said she was shocked on learning about it," High Court Deputy Judge Simon Birt said in his findings.

    "She told [her mother] who said … the family had never discussed selling the diamond and she would never agree to or be happy with its sale."

    Dr Neupert contacted Qipco to back out.

    The "present crisis" of the COVID-19 pandemic, he told the company, meant there was no market for diamonds, and no valuation available.

    The family would not sell.

    High Court weighs in on 'wish' to sell The Idol's Eye

    Meanwhile, Qipco had been in contact with Christie's in order to get the auction house's formal valuation — it ultimately supplied an estimated auction value of $US7-10 million.

    It told Elanus to provide its own valuation so the sale could move forward.

    The matter landed in London's High Court, where an eight-day trial played out over November last year.

    Elanus argued the Swiss lawyer was not acting on the organisation's behalf — and, regardless, it had withdrawn any "wish" to sell.

    "Moreover, it is clear … even if there had been [a] 'wish' on the part of [Sheikh Saud's son] to sell the diamond which could be attributed to Elanus, there was … no longer any such wish [by April]," Judge Birt said.

    "Once Sheikha Sara had discovered the fact that there was a proposal to sell the diamond, and she had in turn informed Sheikha Amna, it is clear that they were both upset at the situation.

    "Sheikha Amna because she did not want it sold at all, and Sheikha Sara mainly because of the steps [her brother] had taken without any consultation with the rest of the family.

    "They both made their feelings very clear."

    The High Court finally dismissed the case on Thursday, local time — Elanus could not be made to sell The Idol's Eye.


    ABC




    © 2025 ABC Australian Broadcasting Corporation. All rights reserved

     Other Law and Order News
     15 Feb: Violence and protests at Auckland Pride events yesterday
     15 Feb: Two people have been taken to hospital after they were seriously injured by a dog in Auckland's Manurewa
     15 Feb: Civil lawsuit accusing Jay-Z and Sean 'Diddy' Combs of rape dropped
     15 Feb: Four people have been charged in the past week in relation to industrial burglaries in South Auckland's Counties Manukau
     15 Feb: Kiwi Nick Cassidy's placed 11th and compatriot Mitch Evans 21st in Formula E's round three event in Jeddah
     14 Feb: Dozens injured as car rams into crowd in Munich — how it unfolded
     14 Feb: Nearly 340 thousand dollars of assets have been seized from a Wellington drug supplier
     Top Stories

    RUGBY RUGBY
    The Brumbies have won a see-sawing Super Rugby Pacific contest in Suva, beating the Fijian Drua 36-32 More...


    BUSINESS BUSINESS
    South Waikato's council is aiming to promote growth in the area despite paper production ending at Tokoroa's Kinleith Mill More...



     Today's News

    Christchurch:
    Fire crews are expected to remain on the ground at Canterbury's Lewis Pass Road over the coming days 5:06

    Politics:
    Elon Musk's DOGE agency is at the centre of controversy in the US. So what is it? 4:36

    Law and Order:
    Violence and protests at Auckland Pride events yesterday 22:26

    Law and Order:
    Two people have been taken to hospital after they were seriously injured by a dog in Auckland's Manurewa 21:56

    Business:
    South Waikato's council is aiming to promote growth in the area despite paper production ending at Tokoroa's Kinleith Mill 20:26

    International:
    Drone attack on Chernobyl nuclear plant casts shadow over peace prospects 19:56

    Rugby:
    The Brumbies have won a see-sawing Super Rugby Pacific contest in Suva, beating the Fijian Drua 36-32 18:56

    Rugby League:
    Hamilton's proven to be a happy hunting ground for the Warriors, as a first-half blitz fuelled a 36-10 win over the Storm 18:36

    Soccer:
    Auckland FC intend to make up for the biggest blip in their debut A-League men's season when they take on Western United in Melbourne tonight 18:06

    Rugby League:
    The New Zealand Warriors have wrapped up an unbeaten pre-season with today's impressive 36-10 win over the Melbourne Storm in Hamilton 17:46


     News Search






    Power Search


    © 2025 New Zealand City Ltd