News | National
4 Dec 2024 22:13
NZCity News
NZCity CalculatorReturn to NZCity

  • Start Page
  • Personalise
  • Sport
  • Weather
  • Finance
  • Shopping
  • Jobs
  • Horoscopes
  • Lotto Results
  • Photo Gallery
  • Site Gallery
  • TVNow
  • Dating
  • SearchNZ
  • NZSearch
  • Crime.co.nz
  • RugbyLeague
  • Make Home
  • About NZCity
  • Contact NZCity
  • Your Privacy
  • Advertising
  • Login
  • Join for Free

  •   Home > News > National

    The best and worst meat replacements for your health, your wallet and the planet – new research

    Beans are best all round, followed by veggie burgers and lab-grown beef.

    Marco Springmann, Senior Researcher on Environment and Health, University of Oxford
    The Conversation


    By now it’s well established that meat and dairy are at least partly to blame for the climate crisis. And without coming off our addiction to animal products, we won’t be able to avoid dangerous levels of global heating.

    What is less clear is what to replace your burger and cheese with. What’s best for your health and the planet? And what about your wallet? These are the questions I tried to answer in a new study.

    I combined assessments of meat and milk alternatives which compared their nutritional profile, health benefits, environmental impact and cost. Among these plant-based alternatives were traditional products such as tofu and tempeh, processed options such as veggie burgers and plant milks, products still under development such as lab-grown beef and unprocessed foods like soybeans and peas.

    The assessments featured several ways of comparing foods, including per serving or calorie, and on their own or when replacing a person’s present intake of meat and dairy.

    Beans beat the lot

    The findings show that unprocessed plant-based foods, such as soybeans, peas and beans are best suited for replacing meat and dairy.

    Choosing legumes over meat and milk would halve nutritional imbalances – the overall difference between current and recommended intake of nutrients – in high-income countries like the UK, US and across Europe. And it would cut the number of people dying by a tenth, especially from diet-related diseases like heart disease, stroke, cancer and diabetes.

    The amount of land and water needed to grow our food and the amount of greenhouse gas emissions produced as a result would more than halve, and food costs would fall by more than a third.

    Four bar charts comparing meat and milk alternatives.
    Beans, pulses and traditional products like tempeh trounced the opposition. Springmann (2024)/PNAS

    Veggie burgers and plant milks in second

    Processed plant-based foods such as veggie burgers and plant milks still offer substantial benefits for anyone seeking to replace meat and dairy. But the emissions reductions and health improvements were a fifth to a third less than what unprocessed legumes offer, and costs to the consumer were a tenth higher than those of current diets.

    For both processed and unprocessed alternatives, most of the improvements in nutrition and disease risk came from increases in fibre (though processed alternatives tend to contain less), potassium and polyunsaturated fatty acids, and from reductions in cholesterol, saturated fat and animal-based (heme) iron.

    Both processed and unprocessed plant-based alternatives had a lower environmental impact than meat and milk, as they generate less emissions and consume less land and water to make.

    Processing food, by making veggie burgers and plant milks for instance, requires energy, which typically raises costs and emissions. However this does not eclipse the environmental benefits compared with meat and dairy. It does mean that processed alternatives typically cost more than unprocessed ones.

    A hand holding a chickpea plant.
    Legumes, like this chickpea plant, nourish the soil with nitrogen and require less chemical fertiliser to grow. SGr/Shutterstock

    So, unprocessed legumes such as peas and beans were the clear winner in the study. They performed well from all perspectives, including nutrition, health, environment and cost.

    But a surprising runner-up was tempeh, a traditional Indonesian food made from fermented soybeans, which retains much of the nutritional properties of soybeans without much processing or additives. This, and its relatively low cost, gave it an edge over more processed alternatives such as veggie burgers.


    Read more: Meat and dairy gobble up farming subsidies worldwide, which is bad for your health and the planet


    Lab-grown in last place

    Another surprising finding concerned lab-grown meat. Despite the difficulty of assessing a product that is not yet on the market, existing data suggests it will not be competitive with meat alternatives, nor meat from slaughter.

    Using current technology that consumes a lot of energy to grow animal tissue in a lab, cultured meat’s emissions can be as high as those of beef burgers while costing up to 40,000 times more. By replicating beef, the health impacts of lab-grown meat are similarly bad.

    Although costs and emissions could fall as production processes become more efficient, this would require substantial investment and technological advancements.

    A slab of meat in a petri dish held by a gloved hand.
    Lab-grown meat is a costly alternative to meat from slaughter. Oleksandra Naumenko/Shutterstock

    Public investment in both lab-grown meat and ultra-processed plant-based replacements may not be justified considering their relative impacts. Readily available alternatives are affordable and do not call for new technologies or product development.

    What is required, however, are prudent public policies that support everyone to eat healthily and sustainably.

    It’s worth saying that the best replacements for meat and dairy are not only whole foods, but whole meals. Why not try to cook a bean chilli, chickpea curry, or tempeh stir-fry? Or, how about some crushed peas on dark bread?

    Replacing your average fast-food meal with a mix of legumes, veggies and whole grains offers not only a more balanced serving of nutrients but also lowers your environmental footprint at a similar or lower cost to your wallet.


    Imagine weekly climate newsletter

    Don’t have time to read about climate change as much as you’d like? Get our award-winning weekly roundup in your inbox instead. Every Wednesday, The Conversation’s environment editor writes Imagine, a short email that goes a little deeper into just one climate issue. Join the 40,000+ readers who’ve subscribed so far.


    The Conversation

    Marco Springmann receives funding from Wellcome Trust through a Career Development Award (Award number: 225318/Z/22/Z) and the EU Horizon Programme through the projects BrightSpace (Grant agreement number: 101060075) and CATALYSE (Grant agreement number: 101057131).

    This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license.
    © 2024 TheConversation, NZCity

     Other National News
     04 Dec: Police are going door-to-door in Tokoroa looking for information on the mysterious death of Shane Edwards
     04 Dec: More than 500 days after Christchurch Real Estate Agent Yanfei Bao went missing, a man has been found guilty of her murder
     04 Dec: A lucky rescue for three people who flipped their boat flipped on the Raglan Bar - at just the right time
     04 Dec: Mainland Poultry is in full response mode, dealing with bird flu on one of its Otago farms
     04 Dec: A person has been seriously injured after a truck collided with a vehicle in Auckland's Kumeu
     04 Dec: A scrub fire along Wellington's train corridor isn't impacting services
     04 Dec: A former Auckland contract manager is facing almost four-and-a-half-years behind bars - having pleaded guilty to fraud and corruption
     Top Stories

    RUGBY RUGBY
    All Blacks second five Jordie Barrett is ready for more rugby to close out 2024 as he embarks on a temporary chapter abroad More...


    BUSINESS BUSINESS
    Trademarks that will never be used can be ‘bad faith’ business – a UK case has lessons for NZ and Australia More...



     Today's News

    Basketball:
    Expect the Breakers to trial-and-error some defensive schemes around 7-foot-6 centre Tacko Fall moving forward 21:57

    Entertainment:
    Cardi B has been "partying hard" since her split from Offset 21:44

    Law and Order:
    Police are going door-to-door in Tokoroa looking for information on the mysterious death of Shane Edwards 21:17

    Entertainment:
    Selena Gomez doesn't "need anyone's approval" 21:14

    Entertainment:
    Kerry Katona was left terrified when masked thugs raided her property while she was at home 20:44

    Entertainment:
    Meghan, Duchess of Sussex is reportedly preparing to launch her lifestyle brand and her new Netflix show in the New Year 20:14

    Entertainment:
    Blur's Alex James almost went bankrupt when work dried up during the COVID-19 lockdowns 19:44

    Entertainment:
    Lala Kent doesn't intend to "reach out" to her 'Vanderpump Rules' co-stars after she was axed from the show 19:14

    International:
    South Korean President Yoon Suk Yeol could be facing impeachment after martial law declaration — here's what that process looks like 19:07

    Politics:
    More than 112-thousand people are homeless in New Zealand 18:57


     News Search






    Power Search


    © 2024 New Zealand City Ltd