News | International
13 Aug 2020 0:44
NZCity News
NZCity CalculatorReturn to NZCity

  • Start Page
  • Personalise
  • Sport
  • Weather
  • Finance
  • Shopping
  • Jobs
  • Horoscopes
  • Lotto Results
  • Photo Gallery
  • Site Gallery
  • TVNow
  • Dating
  • SearchNZ
  • NZSearch
  • Crime.co.nz
  • RugbyLeague
  • Make Home
  • About NZCity
  • Contact NZCity
  • Your Privacy
  • Advertising
  • Login
  • Join for Free

  •   Home > News > International

    Hydroxychloroquine is a poor coronavirus treatment but a perfect parable for our times

    Thanks to social media, the anti-malarial drug is no longer a potential COVID-19 treatment but an ideological position.


    The group had all the trappings of medical authority.

    Wearing white coats as they stood with serious faces in front of the US Supreme Court earlier this week,they called themselves "America's Frontline Doctors".

    In the video of their press conference, which was livestreamedon Facebook, the group promoted a familiar but controversial narrative: that the drug hydroxychloroquine could help treat COVID-19.

    They made their claims despite large scientific studies showing the drug doesn't benefit people hospitalised with the disease.

    The original clip was removed from Facebook but it lived on, with a retweet from US President Donald Trump and a boost on Instagram from celebrities like Madonna. After that, right-wing and conspiratorial online communities — including those in Australia — made a point of keeping the video available online.

    Even a transcript of the press conference, on the website of transcription service Rev, has received more than 800,000 interactions on Facebook, according to data from social media monitoring firm Crowdtangle. It has been posted more than 500 times.

    The video controversy is only the latest instalment in the saga of hydroxychloroquine's transformation, from relatively obscure anti-malarial drug to political football.

    It first arrived in the spotlight thanks to widespread press coverage and now, in private Facebook groups and in YouTube comment feeds, hydroxychloroquine is no longer just an unlikely medicine for COVID-19.

    To believe in its efficacy is often a way to indicate support for President Trump or an ideological scepticism of the medical establishment, entirely disconnected from the science.

    "It's a tenet of faith," said Tom Sear, a fellow with UNSW Canberra Cyber at the Australian Defence Force Academy. "All the scientific evidence is doubtful — and there's Trump with certainty."

    Where did the hype come from?

    As coronavirus spread in early 2020, the world scrambled for a silver bullet and the antimalarial drug hydroxychloroquine — or HCQ — emerged as an early candidate.

    Also used to treat lupus and rheumatoid arthritis, it had shown some promise when used against two previous coronaviruses, SARS and MERS.

    "The hope was it might be somewhat useful," said Derek Lowe, a long-time drug discovery researcher and author of In the Pipeline, a long-running science blog on the Science Translational Medicine website.

    "No-one expected great things out of hydroxychloroquine."

    On Facebook, some of the first mentions of the drug as a potential COVID-19 treatment came in mid-February from Chinese media like Xinhua and China Daily but attracted relatively little engagement.

    Outside the research community, however, the real attention came after the intervention of a media-savvy French microbiologist named Didier Raoult.

    His study, published in the Journal of Antimicrobial Agents in March, tested a combination of hydroxychloroquine and the antibiotic azithromycin on patients with COVID-19 and found that it helped.

    But in the eyes of other scientists, the study was decidedly lacklustre. It was small and uncontrolled, which meant there was no group that did not receive the treatment to compare the results against.

    But those caveats, and underwhelming results from other trials, ceased to hold much weight in the greater public consciousness after US President Donald Trump weighed in.

    On March 19, Trump said the drug could be a "game changer" at a White House news conference with his coronavirus task force. A few days later, he tweeted a link to Dr Raoult's study. It was retweeted more than 300,000 times.

    Since March 1, public posts containing the word "hydroxychloroquine" have received at least 55 million "interactions" on Facebook — a measure that includes reactions, shares or comments.

    Other cable news characters emerged as willing soldiers in a burgeoning culture war, such as Dr Vladimir Zelenko, a doctor in upstate New York who claimed to have treated patients with a combination of hydroxychloroquine and other drugs.

    And in the months since, President Trump and members of his administration have repeatedly returned to the hydroxychloroquine narrative despite the protests of White House medical advisor Dr Anthony Fauci, who has repeatedly stated that all "valid" scientific data suggests hydroxychloroquine is not effective against COVID-19.

    The drug has attracted the attention of populist politicians outside the United States as well.

    It's been heavily promoted by Brazilian President Jair Bolsonaro, and the drug even became a political instrument in Australia, when erstwhile MP Clive Palmer bought Facebook ads in March, as well as full-page newspaper ads, promoting his proposal to buy "1 million doses" of the drug to support the fight against COVID-19.

    Hydroxychloroquine was seized upon because it offered an appealing narrative, Mr Lowe suggested: a cheap, immediate cure. And if there were naysayers, those were just evil forces at work.

    "There was an element of sticking it to the 'big evil' drug companies — 'we're going to use this cheap generic medicine that's been around forever'."

    It is a political drug now

    Of course, the attraction of a miracle cure is nothing new. But the media and social media platforms can amplify and convert this desire into an article of faith, often tied to politics and identity.

    If it were effective, hydroxychloroquine might offer an immediate and individualistic solution that could appeal to those on the right, Mr Sear said, in opposition to more left-leaning values around social responsibility.

    "[Hydroxychloroquine is] characterised as a quick fix, a magic cure for the 'problem' of the virus," he said of how the drug is often characterised online.

    "It's not a social solution. It doesn't imply we have to work together — and with government — and address larger, more complex, and interrelated issues in society to battle the disease."

    Throughout the pandemic, the spruiking of so-called coronavirus "treatments" has been widespread — grifters adapting to the current panic by offering unproven solutions such as colloidal silver.

    But hydroxychloroquine is different, according to Elise Thomas, a misinformation researcher at the Australian Strategic Policy Institute.

    "The reality is, most of these people have no knowledge of what hydroxychloroquine is," she said.

    "From that angle, it does become more of an article of faith, or more wrapped up into an ideological or political narrative as opposed to being an actual industry that ordinary people can participate in."

    George Buchanan, a researcher at the University of Melbourne, has been observing online discussions about COVID-19 on platforms like YouTube and Twitter.

    Like Ms Thomas, Dr Buchanan has seen hydroxychloroquine picked up by right-wing and pro-Trump circles on social media. He said it remains one of the most discussed potential treatments online.

    "HCQ has been the dominant narrative up to this point."

    The failure of hydroxychloroquine to emerge as a usable COVID-19 treatment so far can be seen as many things by such groups. It might be "evidence" of the pharmaceutical industry's backing of alternative drugs, for example, or an excuse by the "deep state" to eventually vaccinate everyone.

    Ms Thomas described what she calls "conspiracy collapse", where social media platforms bring together many different kinds of sometimes contradictory conspiracies.

    "It's a car crash. It's terrifically messy," she said.

    "You look at it at the end, and you can't figure out what started where."

    What the HCQ misinformation means for a vaccine

    The online obsession with hydroxychloroquine seems unabated — not helped by the media's difficulty in reporting the uncertainty inherent in medical science and drug trials.

    Just in the past seven days, Crowdtangle data shows Facebook posts on pages and in public groups mentioning the drug have received more than 12 million interactions. And posts from right-wing figures such as Dan Bongino and Rush Limbaugh about censorship of the treatment have been shared tens of thousands of times.

    Thanks in part to social media networks and other online coverage, misinformation and conspiracy theories have periodically flowed from the US and Europe into Australia — at times an "information colony", as Mr Sear put it — and hydroxychloroquine is no exception.

    Similar statements of belief in the drug and accusations of cover-ups have been shared widely here in recent days thanks to posts from Australian politicians, wellness influencers and anti-vaccination pages.

    Whether or not hydroxychloroquine ever becomes a viable coronavirus drug, the evolution of its online narrative has created a template for how to muddy the narrative around potential treatments, and especially around any potential vaccine.

    Mr Lowe predicted there is going to be "a lot of craziness" as the vaccine clinical data starts to emerge.

    Ultimately, however, what frustrates him most about the hydroxychloroquine hype is the vast gulf between the appealing narrative it offers and the usual way that medical science advances.

    Most of the drugs that scientists develop, Mr Lowe said, for everything from cancer to coronaviruses, simply do not work. They fail.

    "There aren't very many miracle drugs."

    © 2020 ABC Australian Broadcasting Corporation. All rights reserved


     Other International News
     12 Aug: Five easy ways to lower your household carbon emissions
     12 Aug: Kamala Harris is Joe Biden's VP pick to take on Donald Trump. Here's what you need to know about her
     12 Aug: Four COVID cases were enough for New Zealand to lock down Auckland. Here's what we know
     12 Aug: Joe Biden announces Kamala Harris will be his vice-president pick to take on Donald Trump
     12 Aug: How will the Democratic and Republican conventions be held during the coronavirus pandemic? Here's what we know
     12 Aug: Finding Freedom book details what led to Harry and Meghan's split from royal family
     12 Aug: Papua New Guinea is walking a tightrope on coronavirus, so it's abandoned lockdowns
     Top Stories

    RUGBY RUGBY
    The return to covid-19 level 3 in Auckland spells sporting uncertainty again More...


    BUSINESS BUSINESS
    Reserve Bank Governor Adrian Orr's revealed the events of the last 24 hours did not sway the decision to expand the Quantitative Easing programme More...



     Today's News

    Rugby League:
    The Brisbane Broncos have responded to allegations up to 10 players broke NRL covid-19 protocols 21:57

    Entertainment:
    Lara Asprey and Juan Custodio are expecting a baby boy 21:31

    Health & Safety:
    Experts believe Covid-19 isn't contained in Auckland 21:17

    Entertainment:
    Antonio Banderas has tested positive for Covid-19 21:01

    Entertainment:
    Claudia Schiffer had a security guard to watch her underwear 20:31

    Entertainment:
    Lin-Manuel Miranda says his friendship with Andrew Scott boosted his sex appeal 20:01

    Entertainment:
    Tessa Thompson doesn't worry about her activism affecting her work opportunities 19:31

    Entertainment:
    Brad Pitt and Leonardo DiCaprio have bonded over their love of motorbikes 19:01

    Living & Travel:
    Air New Zealand is prepared for a drop in domestic flights 18:57

    International:
    Five easy ways to lower your household carbon emissions 18:47


     News Search






    Power Search


    © 2020 New Zealand City Ltd